Fasten your seat belts?

Economy turning corner, acceleration seen…

The good news is, the best is yet to come…

If things are going well, you don’t hear it. That probably captures what is going on in the economy. Rural recovery can hardly match rural distress when it comes to television rating points. No one can blame you if you haven’t heard rural recovery as much as rural distress. Teething problems in GST made splashy headlines, but recovery in GST collections and stabilizing e-way bill hardly make even whispers, let alone being fodder for breaking news. So is the case with the visible signs of turnaround in capex cycle, IIP numbers and so on. After long time, one gets to feel that all cylinders at last may be coming together to fire up the economic engine.

Pickup in investment demand:

For the economy, it has been a story of chocked capex cycle for last few years. It has been running only on few cylinders (esp. consumption), while its critical capex (private investment demand) cylinder was too clogged and sputtered to lend any material support. As for the reasons, it wasn’t that difficult to decipher what was at the root of so called investment inertia during that time. Over capacity and gross under-utilization in many sectors led to sharp slow-down in the need for capacity expansion and thus causing serious slump in the investment demand. Back then, the hope was that the sustained consumption demand will eventually lead to higher utilization which in turn will lead to recovery in private investments in early 2017, if not little later. But the two successive disruptions in the form of DeMon and GST, dashed this hope with consumption and the broader economy coming under severe strain under these disruptions for the past 12 months.

Disruption to Delivery:

It is now time for payoff from these disruptions. With the imprints of DeMon fading and with GST gradually gaining traction, consumption is back with vigor, leading to recovery in gross utilization numbers across sectors. Surge in order books reported by companies in the capital goods sector and the acceleration in IIP numbers in the last 3 months are the cases in point and provide evidence to early signs of recovery in investment cycle. Add to this, the optimism on monsoon, agri growth and rural recovery. All these add up as a huge ammunition for the economy to aspire for 8%+ growth sooner, may be as early as FY20, than expected earlier.

One doesn’t need to go too far to find supporting evidence for the afore-said economic narrative than to have quick look at the latest monetary policy commentary from RBI. To quote RBI,

“Turning to the growth outlook, several factors are expected to accelerate the pace of economic activity in 2018-19. First, there are now clearer signs of revival in investment activity as reflected in the sustained expansion in capital goods production and still rising imports, albeit at a slower pace than in January. Second, global demand has been improving, which should encourage exports and boost fresh investment. On the whole, GDP growth is projected to strengthen from 6.6 per cent in 2017-18 to 7.4 per cent in 2018-19 – in the range of 7.3-7.4 per cent in H1 and 7.3-7.6 per cent in H2 – with risks evenly balanced”

Of course, there are macro risks like rising crude and hardening domestic yield including negative global cues such as rising bond yield in US and potential acceleration in fed rate hikes etc that could cause temporary uncertainties. That said, if luck favors a little, we are looking at a huge economic tailwinds and consequently robust corporate earning cycle in the coming months for India.

Markets: Macro to drift, Micro to shine?

Coming to market, in its obsession to price the political/election risk, it has barely noticed the underlying acceleration in the corporate earning cycle. Weakening macro could be another reason why markets are yet to fully price-in the growth acceleration. India had the best of macro during last three years. Falling crude, contained twin deficits (current account and fiscal), strengthening currency, moderate or falling yield etc dominated the economic narrative in these years. That luck seems to have run out now as we begin the next fiscal. Cracks have started creeping in the macro with much of above factors showing signs of reversal.

But the good news is, this macro drift is unlikely to derail the carefully crafted recovery that is underway in the micro (corporate earnings growth). While macro may be losing some of its mojo, growth in the broader economy is coming back with vengeance, giving fillip to corporate earnings growth. Early signs of recovery in the investment demand (capex cycle) couldn’t have come at a better time. Having said that, broader trend for the markets at the index level will continue to be muted given the macro challenges, while improvement in micro in terms of sharp recovery in corporate earnings will drive stock-specific movements in the market. Unlike 2017, which was a year of magical macro, 2018 will be a year of micro with stock specific sizzle steered by progressive revival in the so-far elusive earnings growth. Investors should continue to focus on stock picking and portfolio construction during this dull phase of range bound market to benefit from the eventual breakout that is likely to happen as the acceleration in the economy gathers steam.


Behavioral Edge

To err is human. Except, in investments, errors end up lot more expensive. In most cases, esp. in listed space, such errors are more often caused by emotional short-circuitry than any intellectual shortcomings. Emotional handicaps often occur because of mind’s inherent nature to magnify events that are current and immediate while short circuiting other material events that may not be current. To understand this better, we can try modeling this in a algorithmic fashion. Imagine, we have a computing algorithm that magnifies micro inputs using self-feeding feedback loop and throws magnified outputs based only on “recent”, but minor events, bypassing other rational “past” material inputs. This model would effectively mimic the emotional brain with a behavioral bias.

Investment decisions are supposed to be rational and logical. But in reality, they are anything but that. If investors are rational, then, markets which are nothing but collection of investors, by definition have to be rational. Since we know markets are irrational, we can deduce that investors suffer from significant number of delusional defects that deter them from making sound logical decisions. Though there is a separate stream of finance, called behavioral finance, covers extensively on the various types of cognitive biases, we would like to look at closely one bias that has an outsized impact on investment results.

To understand this special one more, let us look at two investment options in the below illustration and check how investors respond to this situation.


The choice is straightforward, if investors are logical. They should go with option-1 and accumulate/add on every fall. But in practice, what many studies have found is, much of the times, investors chose option-2. What is going on here? It is interesting to note that the emotional circuitry (blind-spots) edges out the logical circuitry in all those cases. Let us examine these blind-spots little more, by looking at the list of behavioral biases that are at play in this decision making:

• Loss aversion bias, even though loss is notional.

• Fear of more downside.
• Recency bias where mind gives more weights to short-term events.
• Tendency to over-estimate one’s ability to time the trend change.

As someone wise said, how one behaves near the top and near the bottom makes all the difference between success and failure in investing. If one has the ability not to freeze into inaction at the edges, then it brings real competitive edge in this business. This means, one has to constantly hone the emotional skills to deal with the greed of making more near the top and to deal with the fear of losing more near the bottom.

Logically speaking, both should be easy because both upside and downside are notional near the edges. But emotional short-circuitry magnifies the greed and fear so as to blind the logical circuitry. Large part of success in investing comes from how one deals with these inner demons that distort the decision cycle thro’ behavioral bias. Edge in investment business comes from simple emotional skills (EQ), not from any intellectual ability to solve three dimensional complex algorithms.

“Moat in investment business comes, not so much from thinking skill, but from silencing the emotional circuitry i.e. honing emotional skills”

Current market weakness is throwing multitude of option-1 type opportunities for investors to grab. It is time to still the mind by silencing the inner demons to capitalize on the market capitulation, not to lose bearings on probable paper losses.

Happy Value Investing!!

Year of Accumulation?

Shine is off from stocks. That is good and should be a welcome relief from the one-way reckless rally that has been ruling the roost for many months in a row. In a rare coincidence, multiple cues came together in a miraculous fashion to conspire a deadly blow to the bloated stocks. Global bond sell-off and tantrums on trade war couldn’t have come at a worse time. Just when the FM was lighting fire with his ill-thought LTCG tax (Long-term capital gains tax), global cues turned negative triggering a slump in Indian stocks. Macro fiscal worries from lavish MSP proposal and other rural largesse added to the ammunition with ten year yield Gsec yield spiking to levels not seen for many months.

All these are not completely unexpected except the eerie coincidence of all coming together. Market is hugely edgy and weighed down by uneasy calm. Weakness in the broader space should be a welcome development for seasoned stock pickers. If 2017 was an unstoppable one-way rally for much of the broader market, with volatility returning this year, 2018 should be viewed by serious investors as an opportune year for accumulation / portfolio building for an eventual breakout in 2019 when the economy starts reaping the rewards of series of structural reforms of past few years which will catapult the GDP growth rates to beyond 8%+.

“Structural reforms such as Bankruptcy code, RERA, Subsidy reforms thro DBT, Indirect tax reforms (GST), Financialization of savings, Inflation control etc. will drive the break-out for the economy from its badly stuck 7-7.5% range from FY20 onwards”

Investors should focus on portfolio construction and stock picking during
this period of volatility (because of weakening macro) by moving more additional investments into equities for benefiting from the eventual breakout that will play out from FY20 onwards. It is time to increase one’s equity exposure in a gradual fashion, not to lose bearings on paper losses.

Happy Value Investing!!


Time to invest, not to time the bottom…

Crack in the market always comes with cacophony. Investors should be wise enough not to wait for cacophony to clear and instead focus on picking undervalued stocks with high margin-of-safety without yielding to the temptation to time the bottom. As someone wise said, if you wait for robins, spring will be over.

Instead of timing, the focus should be on Margin-of-Safety (MOS). Let us turn to the anecdote of coin flipping to understand more on the concept of MOS. As we know, flipping the coin is a risky bet. Is there a way to improve odds in that? What if, heads you win and tails you do not lose? Though odds of winning do not improve, odds of not losing improve to 100%. This is exactly what Margin Of Safety does in investing. Strangely, in investing, when you are focused on downside, upside takes care of itself. Value investing is all about downside protection and MOS is the magnificent tool to mitigate the downside risk. It is the magical concept that magnifies the portfolio returns by denting the drags from losers and by earning exceptional rewards from winners. To quote Ben Graham, “Confronted with a challenge to distil the secret of sound investment into three words, we venture the motto, Margin of Safety”

How does one get MOS in stock picking? If MOS is defined as the discount from the intrinsic value of the underlying business, primarily, it comes from the mis-pricing in the markets. Mispricing can happen on two counts. One from the broader market trend and the other from stock specific scenarios(when underlying business comes across short-term bumps). In general, mispricing is on the upside when the mercury is up and it is on the downside when there is meltdown. It applies both to stock-specific swings and to overall market moves.

The challenge is not so much about getting MOS opportunities. Vicious corrections even in a virtuous bull market are not very unusual. Similarly, stock specific slumps are not scarce in a secular uptrend. The harder part is more about having the nerve to invest when such MOS opportunities arise, as in most cases, the accompanying high decibel narrative numbs the investors into inaction. Take for example the ongoing correction. Last week, small and midcaps were mauled mercilessly (continuing as we write this). For most of the stock prices, the clock was back by one year. Yet, the same people who were waiting on the fence for a sharp correction, turned frozen because of the changed narrative. As they say, money is made not in following narrative, but in following valuations. Narrative will take care of itself as time goes.  MOS grows in manic pessimism. Time to start nibbling is when narrative turns negative. If you wait for cloud to clear, MOS too will mysteriously disappear.

“Current market weakness is nothing but market’s way of adjusting to                                      the weakening macro. Market never adjusts in an orderly fashion. To                                    that extent, as market adjusts to the new macro challenges, expect lot                                    more bumps and humps in the coming months”

But time to bet is when these bumps and humps bombard, not when it becomes seamlessly smooth. While macro may not be at its best, underlying recovery in micro (recovery in corporate earnings) may provide the required support in the medium to long-term.

Happy Value Investing!!

Follow the Cycles, not the Narrative!

“Herd follows the narrative whereas Contrarian follows the Cycles”

Let us start with some interesting facts and then turn to intriguing questions…

Last few weeks have witnessed some dramatic changes in prices in certain asset classes. Oil prices are up by 25 to 30%, IT stocks in India came out of slumber and produced stunning returns, Indian Gsec ten year bonds crashed and globally dollar index is down by over 10%+ etc. Behind these seemingly disconnected events, is there a common thread that is running across?

To explore this, let us turn to the questions.

Why does a 1 to 2% change in forecast for oil demand results in 30%+ change in crude oil price? How does a marginal change in forecast for IT spending galvanizes IT stock prices into frenzy? It doesn’t stop here. Mere 3% change in Govt. borrowing has busted the bond prices by over 15% or marginal change in relative monetary policy stance had an outsized impact on the global currency markets with dollar index diving by over 10%.

What is going on here?

“Market is a huge magnifying machine. Direction, not the magnitude sets up the asset prices in this asymmetric world where frothy financial flows distort everything deviously”

It is the nature of markets to mis-price assets for marginal changes in fundamentals. Changes in fundamentals are not anything rare, constantly occurring, driven by dynamics of business cycles. Much of the times, in such changes in business cycles, mis-pricing gets magnified because of the distortion of flows that gets dictated by amplified narratives that accompanies such cyclical, but marginal changes in magnitude.

One will be able to appreciate this phenomenon more thro’ an illustration. Closer look at the dynamics of IT stocks in various downturns over last several years will offer clues to the phenomenon we are talking about.

As someone wise said, Tech spending that drives stocks prices in IT sector is after-all cyclical and it moves in line with global GDP growth prospects in general and with US growth prospects in particular. That said, it is not that simple. What adds complexity is the variable lag time between GDP growth and IT spending. Lag time has been different in each of the past downturns in IT spending. Where it turns interesting is, every time when tech spending hits cyclical low in the past, narrative turned manically negative amplifying some of the ongoing challenges the Industry faces from time to time.

“In 2002, end of y2k was blown out of proportion as end of IT spending. In 2009, global financial crisis was cited as end of BFSI spending. In 2012, it was the turn of “Euro crisis” ruining IT sector. In 2017, it was digital, automation and AI that will bring end to traditional IT business model”

Below chart captured this brilliantly. It shows, how narrative amplifies the otherwise cyclical downturns into a colossal catastrophe to create great contra investment opportunities for someone who keeps an eye on cycles, not on narratives that follow. This is not to, of course, claim that there are no structural challenges for the sector. As the sector matures and becomes sizable, structural headwinds do come and can’t be wished away. Current structural challenges and the matured size have brought down the sector’s sustainable long-term growth to single digits. The point here is to illustrate how, within the trend-line growth, opportunities are created because of over blown narratives that depresses the stock prices whenever cyclical low happens within the trend-line growth.

Investing is at its best when narrative goes negative.

“Time to invest is when drums are beating, not when trumpets are blaring”

Follow the cycles (mis-pricing), not the narrative for the superior results in investing.

Happy Value Investing!!

Liquidity glut: Best is Behind!

Opportunities ahead for potential mis-pricing in bond and debt market.


First anniversary has come and gone, yet animated arguments still continue on its original motive. You guessed it right, we are talking about DeMon. While opinions are still deeply divided on its broader impact, one area where even its detractors do not seem to disagree is on its benign impact on bank deposits. The sensational midnight move scripted the story of savings-glut that unfolded subsequently. Banks were flooded with deluge of deposits at a time when credit demand was weak, leading to huge surplus in liquidity in the system. Deposit rates fell as a result and led to one of the biggest block-buster year for domestic flows into equities. That is not all. With support coming in from moderating inflation and stable currency (on robust FII flows), RBI rate action was on the dovish side leading to virtuous cycle of ever increasing liquidity in the system.

Surge in MF assets

If there is one business where the currency move left a biggest footprint, it must have been mutual fund industry. As a direct fallout of mid-night move, assets managed by mutual funds across the spectrum soared to historic highs. The industry is staring at a eye-popping surge of 40% in its assets this calendar year. It is no coincidence that the monthly SIP book has nearly tripled to Rs 6000+ Cr from its earlier 2000Cr level. This has brought tremendous stability to the Indian markets which otherwise used to dance to FII’s unpredictable tunes.

Odds stacked against now?

2018 may not be as lucky. Footprint of DeMon is fading. Much of it has been used up in capital markets. One can see the first signs of tightening liquidity in the whole sale deposit rates. Rates in this segment have hardened by over 40 to 50bps in the last couple of months. Unlike the year gone by, there will be a competitive chase for attracting deposits by banks in the coming year. More so, with a likely pickup in credit growth. With much less fiscal elbow room on the fallout of faltering GST revenues, liquidity position is likely to get worse in the short-term, as Govt. won’t be able to come to the rescue by boosting expenditure. Add to this the hardening hawkish undertone of RBI on firming inflation and rising risk of fiscal laxity on growing rural distress, it is difficult to build a case for neither softer rates nor for benign liquidity in the coming year. If this week’s spike in ten year Gsec yield is any indication to go by, bond markets seem to be factoring in a worsening fiscal as well as liquidity scenario for the coming months. Ten year yield surged to 17 months high of 7.3% this week. Even if the RBI keeps the status quo on the repo thro’ the year, rates on the ground will start inching up on tighter liquidity and on higher borrowing costs (higher deposit rates).

Year of Volatility?

If one goes back to early period of the current political administration and looks at some of the predictions for 2018, it was foreseen that this Govt. will gain more control in the upper house by 2018 and hence will steer some significant structural reforms in this year. But in an ironical twist, the current administration is losing some of its political capital in the rural segment precisely when it is gaining more control in the upper house, as reflected in the recently concluded state polls. Unlike the state in which polls got concluded recently, the states where series of polls have been lined up in 2018 have much larger share of rural population. Given this and the incumbency risks, it is not difficult to fathom a volatile period on account of noisy political narrative in the coming year. The economic backdrop is unlikely to be benign either. Rising interest rates, tightening liquidity, continued delay in earnings recovery, volatile crude amid normalization of rates in US etc are likely to keep 2018 much more volatile than the smooth ride we have seen in the current year.

Come back time for Debt

For debt investors, opportune time may be on cards. Short-term rates are likely to firm up and that should entice the savers back to debt markets. Investors who wants to add a kicker to the coupon thro’ duration play (like the Gsec/gilt funds), good times may come soon as we expect ten year yield to spike in the early part of 2018 on tightening liquidity amid rising risks of fiscal laxity in the upcoming budget on pressures from the rural constituency to splurge on populist measures. Opportune time is not limited only to debt investors. The rub-off will be there on equities as well. Given the heightened valuations at which equities are trading, rocky narrative both on political and fiscal side will make the coming year more volatile times compared to the one-way run in the year gone by.

Happy New Year!


When negatives get ignored…

In a sign of growing, but dangerous complacence among investors, markets scaled all time high on a day when the ten year Gsec yield spiked to 17 months high of 7.3%. That is not all. Market in its manic rush to breach the next barrier (on the upside of course), it seems to be ignoring all round negative news-flow. Take a look at this. Crude is at a multi-year high. Interest rates are hardening on tightening liquidity and on rising inflation risks. GST collections are on steady decline month after month. Equity FIIs are on sell mode in December. Primary market supplies (IPOs, QIPs and Offer for Sale) are on all time high. On pipeline of supply of papers from Govt.(divestment), there is no sign of slowdown. IIP numbers continue to be patchy and do not inspire confidence on the ever elusive earnings recovery.

It does not stop there. Fiscal worries have come back to haunt the bond markets. If Govt.’s latest demand for additional borrowings of 50,000 Cr is any indication, fiscal slippage could be over 30bps in the current year (fiscal deficit target of 3.2% will be breached and the actual number will be around 3.5%+). Bond markets seem to have expected this shock and factored part of this surprise with the ten year yield spiking to level not seen in the last many months.

Yet, stock market has not given up on making new highs. Where is the dis-connect?

It is not that all these negatives have sprung overnight. They have been in the making for a while. But so far, strong and surging domestic liquidity offered the counter narrative. Domestic flows were so strong that weak fundamentals did not matter much to the markets that were in a hurry to make the next highs. It may not be so any longer with early signs of trouble for liquidity as reflected by hardening rates in the short-end of the yield spectrum and rising whole sale deposit rates.

Then why markets are ignoring all warnings? Probably, this is what happens when market goes thro’ a one way run without any major blip for 12 consecutive months. To borrow from Buffett, nothing sedates rationality like the large doses of effort-less money. Market participants seem to be under serious intoxication by easy money. This is not to say that one should sell and scoot from the markets. That is not what we intend to say here. Though the long-term positive outlook is still intact, in the short-term, given the elevated valuations and emerging short-term risks, pruning positions selectively (stock specific) to build cash levels is critical to navigate the volatile times that may be in store.

Wish you a very Happy New Year!!