Importance of staying invested


There seems to be no end to the surprises the year 2020 can bring. Whether it is in pandemic breakout or in stock market recovery, 2020 refuses to play to the script. If one looks at the past down-cycles, they have always played out as per good old script. That is, in down-cycle, economy goes through a huge deleveraging cycle with far reaching impacts on corporates balance sheets and investors risk appetite. Highly levered corporates find the going tough in a risk-off environment with many of them folding up. Over time, once the leverage risks completely play out (after many bankruptcies and blow-outs), risk-appetite returns to turn the cycle back. It took anywhere between 8 to 12 months for the entire deleveraging cycle to play out. This is how a typical down-cycle transpired in earlier occasions. But no longer so. With its progressively innovative back-stop, Fed has provided such a vast safety net (even to the extent of buying junk bonds from the market in its new QE avatar (Quantitative Easing)) to risk takers, there is a new fancy curve (deleveraging) that is getting flattened ferociously. While one can debate whether US Govt. has successfully flattened the Covid curve or not, when it comes to this deleveraging curve, there is absolutely no debate on the Fed’s success on flattening this one, at least for now.

Now, coming to the more interesting part of this thread, that is, the impact of this innovative flattening on the stock prices globally. While the Governments, across the world, seem to be treading carefully on the dreaded disease with its phased unlocking, in the stock market, there is a new spirit of unlocking that is unfolding in an adventurous manner, driven primarily by the Fed’s flattening. Globally, stock prices made a stunning comeback in this quarter with most of the indices up by over 35 to 40% from March lows (including all emerging markets). To appreciate the power of this renewed surge, one doesn’t need to look far beyond what is happening to NASDAQ. It is now trading near all-time high.

While one can debate whether this liquidity driven rally can sustain or not, esp. in this Covid driven economic disruptions, when Fed’s safety net stretches to “Whatever it takes” shape, one has to reconcile to the fact that this humungous money tap will find its way to stock prices before it finds its ways to the economy. Having said that, while one should respect the power of liquidity, one should not trust it completely. Needless to say, liquidity can be very fickle.

Moving beyond, let us talk about an interesting shift one is sensing in this turnaround rally. It looks like a fundamental shift in the structure of the rally. For the first time in the last two and half years, one is witnessing a broad based rally in the current turnaround. In earlier occasions, whenever the market rallied on liquidity support, it used to be limited to few narrow stocks in the top-end, leaving the broader small and mid-cap segment languishing. This is not limited only to India. Globally, one is witnessing such a turnaround for small-cap stocks after a long lull for over two years. Looking at Russel 2000 – the US Small Cap Index – has come back in this global rally with a 50% spurt from lows after two long years of under-performance.

Does this signal a very material turnaround globally for small-caps (including those in Emerging Markets) and points to a structural turn for small-cap space in India? Of course, while the short-term economic disruptions on account of Covid will continue to be an overhang for the overall markets, this structural shift in small-caps will lead to substantial sequential returns over next few years (once normalcy returns to economy) as we have seen in the past such cycles i.e. Small-cap index surged by whopping 124% in 2009 after the downturn in 2008 and similarly, in 2014 recovery, it delivered a stunning return of over106%.  Similar level of upside in the small-cap index can’t be ruled out over next one year period (or max two years), esp. when most of the weaker hands are out during the panic March fall from many stocks that suffered indiscriminate selling.

If the past three months rally had shown anything, it is this: One can never over-emphasize the power-of-staying-invested, as markets will always surprise.  Investors who rushed to exit citing the Covid narrative, during the March mayhem, are frustratingly waiting for better entry points after the stunning rally in much of the broader space.  Just to share the data-point, BSE small-cap index is up by over 33%+ while the Sensex is up by over 25%+ from the 31st March level.  This doesn’t mean that the risk of markets touching another low in the short-term has gone away. But, taking a longer view, the upside from current level could surprise even seasoned investors, esp. in the smaller end.

Stay the course and stay invested for reaping the full rewards from the longer-term turnaround.

Happy Value Investing!!!

(This article of mine was published in the online edition of Financial Exp. on 17-07-2020. Glad to share the link:



Sell-on-rallies to Buy-on-dips?



In the contest  between liquidity push (driving up the prices) and economic pull (downward pressure on the prices), liquidity seems to be winning hands down for now.  Given the “what-ever it takes” approach from Fed, the nature of this contest is unlikely to change anytime soon.

More importantly, the come-back of small-caps globally after a two year lull marks a major milestone for the structure of the ongoing rally. With small-Caps doing better than large caps (for the first time in the last 30 months) in the current rally, are we in for a decisive turn for the broader markets? If so, what is driving this change? Liquidity alone can’t fully explain this changing dynamics. Because, in earlier occasions, during liquidity driven rally, markets have spared the rally for small-caps (globally) with a sinister design. So, if it is not liquidity, what else?

First and foremost, all directional shifts start from Uncle Sam. It is no different for the structural shift in small-caps. Small-cap index in US (Russel 2000) has taken a decisive turn after the March correction. It is up by over 50% from March lows. As many veteran investors are alluding to, this sharp bounce in small-caps in US is a key factor responsible for the global rally in small-caps across emerging markets. India is no exception to this global phenomenon.

Of course, there are other factors that have worked in the periphery to fuel the rally in small-caps here in India such as:

  • Most of the weaker hands are out during the manic fall in March leading to reduced selling pressure in small-cap space.
  • Some level of reversion from “priced-to-bankruptcy” level of distressed prices in March.
  • Indiscriminate selling driven by redemptions in PMS/HNIs have more or less played out.
  • New buyers emerging on the back of decisive turn in global small-cap segment.

While liquidity can be fickle, some of the above factors could provide a major support to the broader space from hereon. With the visible confidence coming back to broader segment, structure of the market is slowly changing from sell-on-rallies to buy-on-dips. This doesn’t mean that the volatility will not come back to haunt the markets again. With Covid overhang, that risk is unlikely to go away anytime soon.